“Well isn’t it to the imagination?” Windey, 31, teased. “Fantasy?”

Recchia, 26, took a more practical response to the question, clearing up misconceptions that viewers have about the long-running ABC dating competition show’s most iconic milestone.

“I feel like what a lot of people don’t know is [the fantasy suite is] your one time off-camera to talk to them, and it’s the first time you’re really having a conversation that’s not in front of a camera,” she told Anderson. “So it’s so important, however you choose to use it.”

Jimmy Kimmel Live

Bachelorettes Gabby & Rachel on the Fantasy Suite and Their Journey Together

Both Windey and Recchia have a notable history with the fantasy suite. On the last season ofThe Bachelor, where they were vying forClayton Echard’s heart, they were each intimate with him during their individual fantasy suite dates — causing Susie Evans, who was with them among the top 3, to leave the show.

For more onThe Bachelorette, listen below to our daily podcast PEOPLE Every Day.

Though Echard had told all three women they loved him, he wound upbreaking up with Recchi and Windey and pursued a relationship with Evans, but she turned him down and left. Evans then reached out to him post show and they got back together before the live “After the Final Rose” episode. They’re currently still together.

“I feel like we both went through so much on our last season,” she said. “We grew so much, so to be able to have this opportunity has been so amazing after everything we went through. But you know, we feel so ready for it, so we’re excited.”

“It was a journey like it all is and we grew empowered and we’re grateful to have our own,” added Windey.

Susie Evans Instagram

Clayton Echard and Susie Evans

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

This is the first time in the franchise that two bachelorettes will be looking for love at the same time, and the ladies told Anderson they found out about this venture “with the rest of the world.”

Jimmy Kimmel Live!airs weeknights at 11:30 p.m. ET on ABC.The Bacheloretteairs Mondays at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.

source: people.com