A neat book does n’t of necessity make for a great pic , but can a heavy movie fall from a not - so - great book ?
In response tothis review of the unexampled plus to the Hunger Gamesmovie trilogy , commenterSmoothieKingasked a question : Can a book you did n’t revel be work into a movie you do enjoy ? Sure , say some commenters , in fact in some cause a book that did n’t verbalize to you may make a expert on - screen prompting than a book that you loved :
falseprophet
While I good disaccord with your appraisal of Mockingjay the book , the result is , yes , a “ bad ” book can be made into a serious flick ( although it might be more accurate to say a fair or forgettable book ) . In fact , it ’s probably easier to make a secure movie out of a mediocre book than a great Bible , because among other thing a ) good actors can breathe life into character that are somewhat flat on the page , b ) the filmmakers do n’t feel as pressured to treat a average deal - boiler as church doctrine compared to a much beloved classic , and c ) in general , pulpier stories often swear on visceral thing like action and alien scene , and salutary directors , art departments , and SFX crews can really outdo the writer with these .
Some examples :
Almost no one remembersthe Christian Bible Who Framed Roger Rabbit ? was base on .
The Godfather remove a whole fifth of the original novel ( a direful and senseless side story about Sonny ’s mistress getting vaginal surgery ) and move a few flashback about young Vito Corleone to the 2nd movie , where it ’s paired with newfangled cloth about Michael ’s reign as paterfamilias of the Corleone syndicate . This was all to the advance of the photographic film serial . It help that Mario Puzo was so unforced to take a hatchet to his own novel when he co - wrote the screenplay .
Chuck Palahniukthought the film edition ofFight Clubwas really better than his book in some ways .
King ’s Ransom was just one of Ed McBain ’s dozens of 87th Precinct police procedurals . Akira Kurosawa adapted it into theextremely well - receivedHigh and Low .
Casablanca wasbased on the “ world ’s worst play”but is now one of the most extremely - regarded and beloved classics of Golden Age Hollywood .
BooksMovies
Daily Newsletter
Get the best technical school , skill , and polish news in your inbox daily .
News from the futurity , delivered to your present .
You May Also Like
