Is drink a bottle of vino really equivalent to smoke 10 cigarettes ?
It is if you are a woman . At least , that is the ending researcher at the University of Southampton , UK , came to in an clause publish in the journalBMC Public Health .
The generator behind the study say they have calculate the increased rank life-time risk of alcoholic beverage - related Crab associated with a weekly bottle of wine and compared it to the increase rank Cancer the Crab endangerment associated with a 10 - butt - a - week habit .
Men do a little honest . For them , a nursing bottle of wine is equivalent to five cigarette .
Using data collected by Cancer Research UK , the team calculated the increased absolute lifespan cancer endangerment for non - smokers relate with a bottle of wine per week . For women , that increase was 1.4 percent . For men , the figure is 1 percent . Breast cancer seems to be a particular risk concern for alcohol - imbibing woman , whereas drinking is linked to cancers in the liver and GI parcel of land in men .
While no one is arguing that extravagant imbibition is good for you , there are some important restriction to the sketch .
David Spiegelhalter , the Winton Professor for the Public Understanding of jeopardy at Cambridge University , who was not involved in the subject , indicate outthat the overall health impact of moderate drinking “ is still contested ” .
At the same time , John Britton , Director of the UK Centre for Tobacco & Alcohol Studies at the University of Nottingham , explains , weknowsmokers are putting themselves at risk of a range of other serious ailmentsnotconsidered by the subject area – for example , cardiovascular disease .
“ I ’m not sure this sketch sum up much that is utile , ” he added .
Jane Green , the conscientious objector - Director of the Cancer Epidemiology Unit at the University of Oxford , read it ’s all about “ circumstance ” . After all , 1 percent or so might not seem so startling when you consider lifetime endangerment for men and women in the UK already stand at 50 percent .
“ The average UK juicer account drinking the equivalent weight of about a bottle and a one-half of wine a week , and the mediocre smoking car fume about 10 cigarettes a day , or 70 a workweek , ” sheexplained .
“ This work reassert that for most smokers , their smoke gestate much greater risk for cancer than does alcohol for most drinkers . ”
Still , the bailiwick there are some of import take - aways .
“ It is potential that the findings from this simple subject will have a profound effect on the way that drinkers , and in special distaff toper , regard the jeopardy associate with inebriant consumption,”saidBob Patton , Lecturer in Clinical Psychology at the University of Surrey , sharpen out that the risks increase disproportionally for heavier drinkers , with three bottle a hebdomad equating to eight cigaret a workweek for men but 23 coffin nail a week for womanhood .
“ consider alcohol drinking in the same twinkle as cigarette smoke may well result in a decrease in consumption and its come to harms . ”
