When half of the remaining contestants took the stage on Wednesday’s episode ofThe Masked Singer, one came back from a costume malfunction and another caused judgeJenny McCarthyto confess, “I think you broke my botox.”
The singing competition ditched the faceoffs for week four when Flamingo, Leopard, Black Widow, Skelton, Thingamajig and Butterfly gave their second performances of the season.
HostNick Cannonasked the performers for an additional clue after they sang and ultimately the studio audience voted for its favorite singer of the night.
The competitor with the least amount of votes got unmasked, and this week that unlucky contestant was Skeleton, who turned out to beDavid Letterman‘s former musical director and sidekick for theLate ShowandBlues Brothersco-creator Paul Shaffer.
Paul Shaffer.Gary Gershoff/Getty Images

“It gave me a chance to try songs that I never would’ve thought I could pull off in real life,” Shaffer, 69, said after getting unmasked. “And then you say, ‘Hey, I’ll give it a shot. Nobody can see me anyway.'”
Keep reading for the new clues from Wednesday’s episode and to learn who judgesKen Jeong,McCarthy, 46,Nicole ScherzingerandRobin Thickethink the other contestants might be underneath their masks.
Michael Becker / FOX (2)

FLAMINGO
LEOPARD
RELATED VIDEO: ‘Masked Singer’ Host Nick Cannon Admits He Would DM Lizzo ‘For Sure’
Michael Becker/FOX (2)

BLACK WIDOW
SKELETON

THINGAMAJIG
BUTTERFLY
The Masked Singerairs Wednesdays (8 p.m. ET) on Fox.
source: people.com